FIX THE FING DICE!!!

I thought the title was ironically funny in a way though too...
aren't we trying NOT to have "fixed" dice?


Occasional outlier results give me confidence it is indeed mostly randomized. Yes there are the minor black box max rule flips for so-called stat realism etc yadda yadda

That's a good way to look at it. I like that. Although I think we all know the pain of playing in a single park and having a BA monster batting .240. It can definitely drive a guy nuts!

Certainly true for all/any of us.

And how about this thought experiment for this style of ATG competitions:

Imagine you have the top Maddux card against the top Bonds card.
They face each other 500 times.

How should that look? Should Maddux have a 2.00 ERA? But then Bonds hits only 15 HRs?
Now multiply that to fill out an entire staff and lineup of ATG cards. What wins out in these matchups every night?

There are bound to be winners and losers if it is indeed random--I'd be more worried (and also bored) if every player kind of coalesced to some average middle performance.

With a binary competition system (hitter card OR pitcher card at each face-off), there is simply no middle ground