23.3 Results

Greetings,

Here are the results of our 23.3 poll.

To be sent to Strat:
1939 Johnny Mize 1B Cardinals 47
1959 Harmon Killebrew WAS 3B/LF 45
1975 Bill Madlock CHC 3B 42
2021 Carlos Rodon CWS SP 42
1974 Bart Johnson CWS RH SP 41
2014 Joaquin Benoit SD RP 41
2021 Josh Hader MIL LH RP 41
1988 Pascual Perez MON SP 41
2001 Jason Giambi Oakland 1B 40
1990 Barry Bonds Pirates LF 40
1997 Roberto Alomar BAL 2b 40
1955 Mickey Mantle NYY CF 40
1997 JT Snow SF 1b 40
1995 Barry Larkin CIN SS 39
1947 Pee Wee Reese BKN SS 38
1980 Buddy Bell Texas 3B 38
1963 Elston Howard NYY C 38
1969 Mike Andrews 2B Red Sox 38
1974 Dave Rader SF C 38
1947 Ralph Branca Brooklyn SP 35
1944 Snuffy Stirnweiss NYY 2B 35
1919 Babe Ruth Bos LF/RF 32
1951 Gil McDougald NYY 2B-3B 29
1992 John Smoltz ATL SP 28
1928 Del Bissonette BKN 1b 26

To be included in the 23.4 poll:
1936 Gee Walker OF Detroit 25
1984 Dave Collins Toronto LF 24
1908 Bill Burns WSH LH SP 23
1941 Elmer Riddle CIN SP 20
1964 Larry Jackson Cubs RH SP 20
2019 Anthony Rendon WAS 3B 19
1971 Al Downing LHP Los Angeles 19
1947 Eddie Miller CIN SS 19
2019 Yoan Moncada CHW 3B 19
1954 Irv Noren NYY OF 16

Looks like another great add!

Thanks to all who participated.

Bill

Incredible good add, thanks!! Awesome to see Bill Madlock in, deserves that much better card, and we need thirdbasemen.

Good to see three more MVP cards in the set. 25 to go. (27 once this years are announced).

Would be nice to get an exemption to add 2021 deGrom.

Would be nice to get an exemption to add 2021 deGrom.

I don't know, it seems kind of like art imitating life that there's a deGrom out there that we don't truly get the chance to see.

In addition, that card would probably be the best SP card in the set. It's too small a sample size for me to want to see him outpace Maddux, Johnson, Pete Alexander.

Would be nice to get an exemption to add 2021 deGrom.

I don't know, it seems kind of like art imitating life that there's a deGrom out there that we don't truly get the chance to see.

In addition, that card would probably be the best SP card in the set. It's too small a sample size for me to want to see him outpace Maddux, Johnson, Pete Alexander.

I get it. That card was a monster in 20XX. Frequently winning CY Young & MVP.