19.1 Voting is open!

Discussion for new cards to add; moderated by Rosie2167

Moderators: Rosie2167, BC15NY

Choose your top 15

Poll ended at Mon Feb 18, 2019 8:00 am

1. 2005 Jonny Gomes TB OF - .282/.372/.534 1R Balance, LF/RF-4(0)e14 - ROY-3, only card is a .50, Rays need more cards!
25
1%
2. 1980 Don Sutton LAN SP 2.21 ERA (led league in ERA) 0.99 WHIP (led league) E Balanced card S7* His 2nd best card, probably priced much more affordably than his 72 card.
67
2%
3. 1964 Bob Allison MIN OF/1B - .287/.404/.553, 2L Balance, LF/RF-3(-1)e3, CF-4(-1)e3, 1b-4e20 - 60s Mystery Set card is valued at $7.26M but top ATG card is $2.04M
43
2%
4. 1970 Jim Perry MIN SP 24-12 3.04 ERA 1.13 WHIP, 1R Balance, S7*, AL Cy Young Award Winner represented only by far lesser 1960 & 65 cards
64
2%
5. 2017 Jose Altuve HOU 2b AL MVP 2017 .346 .410 .547 1-17 Running, 2e11 fielding, 4,6 (19-13) stealing, E balance
111
4%
6. 1970 Alex Johnson CAL LF- .329 AL batting title, .824 OPS, 614 AB , 2R Balance, LF/RF-4(+2)e13 - represented by only 2 lesser, cheap cards
44
2%
7. 1968 Stan Bahnsen NYY SP* - Rookie of the Year / 2.05 ERA, 1.06 WHIP, 1R Balance, S8*/R4 - has 2 lesser carded years (1 SP '72 CHW/ 1 RP '80 MON)
50
2%
8. 2014 Adam Wainwright STL SP 20-9, 2.38 ERA, 1.031 WHIP, 3R Balance, S7(very good shot at the *), 4th time CYA top 3, no other cards in ATG, 2014 is $8.06M
67
2%
9. 1954 Yogi Berra NYY C/3B - .307/.367/.488 2R Balance, C-1(-3)e4, 3b-4e37 - MVP - probably a nice 5 mil card
52
2%
10. 1990 Dave Magadan Mets 1b/3b .328/.417, 5R Balance, 1b-3e3, 3b-4e12, Obp 6 hr/6 trp/28dbl/ 74 bb good platoon played 15 years no card
44
2%
11. 2011 Cole Hamels Phillies SP 14-9 2.79 ERA 0.99 Whip, 3R Balance, S7(tossup on getting the *)/ 2008 World Series MVP/ Star player that does not have a card in the set
65
2%
12.1995 Edgar Martinez SEA DH Best Year BY FAR 639PA (0 INJ) 356/479/628 1.107 OPS, 3L Balance, 1b-4e30, 3b-4e47, DH only will drive the price down, so should be a great DH at any cap. (Won't be DH only, very playable at 1b)
110
4%
13.1986 Hubie Brooks MON SS/3B .340/.388/.569, 3L Balance, SS-3e32(not eligible at 3b), Not the best defence, but man can he hit. I had him for a full season in the 80's game, he ended up with 233 hits and 46 hr's. A fun card!
69
2%
14. 1981 Nolan Ryan, Astros - unfortunately strike-interrupted, but his was Ryan's best season - 1.69 ERA | 195 ERA+ | 2.28 FIP, 3L Balance, S7 (no idea how they will treat the strike, he is doubtful for the *)
109
4%
15. 1920 Happy Felsch CWS CF DO-40 TR-15 HR-14 RBI-115 BA-.338 OBA-.384 SLG-.540, 2R Balance, CH-1(0)e9
53
2%
16. 2015 Jeurys Familia NYM CL 2-2 1.85 ERA 43 SV 1.00 WHIP, 1R Balance, R1, better card than 2016 with club record 51 saves.
29
1%
17.1993 Paul Molitor Toronto Blue Jays .332avg/.402obp 22/5/37/111rbi77 bb 22sb over 680 plate appearances and world series mvp, 3L Balance, 1b-4e21
48
2%
18.1950 Art Houtteman DET SP/RP 19-12 3.54 ERA 1.30 WHIP, 2R Balance, S9*/R3 - Selected to All Star Team - Ace of the 2nd Place Tigers - AND he was ONLY 22 yrs OLD
25
1%
19. 1888 Silver King, StL, RHP, 45-20, 1.63 ERA, 64 CG. 0.874 WHIP, 584.2 IP, 6 HR allowed. E Balance, S9*
71
3%
20. 1967 Orlando Cepeda, STL, 1B, DO-39, HR-25, RBI-111, BA- .325 OBP-.399 SLG - .524 League MVP for the champs.... 4L Balance, 1b-2e11
50
2%
21. 1973 Fred Beene - NYY - SP & RP - 6-0, 1.68 ERA - 91 INNINGS 67 HITS, 1.03 WHIP, 3R Balance, S6/R4
32
1%
22. 2011 Jose Bautista tor 447 on base 1056 ops MVP3, 302/447/608, 2L Balance, RF-3(-3)e9, 3b-3e14
65
2%
23. 1894 Tuck Turner .418 bave w/Phillies, 416/453/540, 2R Balance, RF/LF/CF-4(+3)e25
32
1%
24. 1969 Don Kessinger - Best overall career season offensively, All Star, 15th in MVP Voting, 737 plate appearances (bulletproof) and won a Gold Glove with a career high fielding %. 3R Balance, SS-2e21
57
2%
25. 1969 Andy Messersmith, Angels, SP & RP, 2.52 ERA, 1.08 Whip, 250 innings, 211Ks, gives Angels another solid SP, E Balance, S8*/R3
45
2%
26.1991 Otis Nixon - ATL OF .297/.371/.327. Fun player, 72 SB in a 124 games, 1L Balance, CF/LF/RF-2(+2)e5, *2-7,11/-(18-16)
49
2%
27. 2011 Ian Kinsler - TEX 2B .255/.355/.477 32 HR 30/34 SB, 2b-2e12, 1L Balance, *4,5/-(19-13)
29
1%
28. 1952 Ferris Fain -- PHA -- .327/.438/.429/.867, 43 doubles, 105 walks, good for small ball teams, plus-600 plate appearances, E Balance, 1b-1e23
43
2%
29. 1999 Rey Ordonez NYM His best year & Gold Glove Shortstop, 258/319/317, 2R Balance, SS-1e4
38
1%
30. 1966 Willie Stargell PIT Bats L, , 315/381/581, 5R Balance, 1b-3e4, LF/RF-3(-3)16
63
2%
31. 2013 JJ Hardy BAL ss 1e12, 644 PA, 25 HR, .265/.306/.433, 1L Balance
21
1%
32. 1972 Carlton Fisk BOS, Bats R, 293/370/538, E Balance, C- 1(-3)e8 will be most usable Fisk card
82
3%
33. 1993 Jeff Blauser Atl Bats R .305/.401/.436 gives Atl another decent exp SS option, E Balance, SS-3e21
15
1%
34. 1922 Charlie Hollocher CHC Bats L 340/403/444 ss-2e30, E Balance
31
1%
35. 1894 Lave Cross SS .387/.424/.526, 1L Balance, 3b-1e65, SS-4e60, 2b-4e71, C-4(+4)e6 (Strat will probably mitigate the errors)
29
1%
36. 1963 Hank Aaron MIL, Bats R, .319/.391/.586, 44 HR, 130 RBI, 31 Steals (*4,6/-19-13), 1R Balance, RF-1(-2)e7, His Best WAR season, 1R card would be a good counterbalance to his 11m 4L card & 8.90 3L card
91
3%
37. 1937 Joe DiMaggio NYY, Bats R, 346/412/673, E balance, CF-1(0)e17 his career highs in HR, RBI, Slugging
78
3%
38. 1954 Ted Kluszewski, 1B Reds, Bats L .326/.407/.642/1.049., 4R Balance, 1b-4e6, Led N.L. in HRs (49) and RBI (141). Career highs in BA, HR, RBI, BB, OBP, SLG, OPS, OPS+ & TB. 2nd in MVP voting to HOFer Willie Mays. Batted .347 36 104 .437 .706 1.143 vs. RHP and a respectable .287 13 37 .340 .518 .858 vs. LHP. This card would be a big improvement over Big Klu's chronically under performing $6 mil card.
98
3%
39. 1884 Fleetwood Walker, C Toledo, First African-American MLB Player, 263/325/316,E Balance, C-3(0)e16, LF-5(0)e25
22
1%
40. 1979 Oscar Gamble, OF/DH Texas & Yankees, Bats L .358/.456/.609/1.065, 19 HRs, 64 RBI in 327 PA. 1R Balance, LF/RF-4(0)e12, Career highs in BA, OBP, SLG, OPS & OPS+. In 235 ABs vs. RHPs, batted .370 16 57 .468 .617 1.085, and was respectable vs. lefties, with .282, 3 HRs in 39 AB.
73
3%
41. 1883 Jim Whitney, SP, Boston Beaneaters, 514 innings pitched, 37-21 W-L, gave up 128 ER and just 7 HR, walked only 35 and struck out 345, WHIP of 1.025, 2R Balance, S9*/R3
24
1%
42. 1899 JOHN MCGRAW 3B-- Fantastic offense-- .391 BA, .547 OBP, 73 SBs -- this should be a premier leadoff card.... 1R Balance, 3b-3e41
91
3%
43. 2010 Carlos Ruiz C - .302/.400/.447 , 2L Balance, C-1(-2)e1 - "Chooch", hugely popular player in Philly, one of the better catchers around for a few years, this was his second best year but more representative of his prime (and his highest finish in MVP vote - 17th). Should be fun, less expensive ATG C option esp for Phillies fans!
37
1%
44. 1919 Hod Eller SP 19-9 2.39era 137K, E Balance, S7*/R5, Won games 5 and 8 of 1919 Black Sox series for Reds, when approached by gambler to lose game 8 Eller threatened to punch him "Square in the nose"
29
1%
45. 2017 Max Scherzer SP WAS 16-6 SO 268 ERA 2.51. WHIP 0.90, 8R Balance, S7 (50/50 on receiving the *)
69
2%
46. 1950 Eddie Yost 3B 1e31 .295 avg .440 obp .405 slg, E Balance - The Walking Man's best card would be great for the top of the order. We could use more cards like Yost in the set.
61
2%
47. 1971 Steve Mingori, Indians, LHRP, 1-2 1.43 ERA 0.971 WHIP, 2R Balance, R2. Career bests in in ERA, WHIP, HR9, H9 (an amazing 4.9).
53
2%
48. 2012 Miguel Cabrera, Detroit. The Triple Crown year. MVP and Batting Champ. This card is a 4R, so it's not only historic, but nice for those Minute Maid teams. 330/393/606, 4R Balance, 3b-4e14 1b-4e14
99
4%
49. 2000 Ivan Rodriguez, Texas. AVG .347/OBP .375/SLG .667, E Balance, C-1(-5)e1 It was easily his best hitting card. It has a bad injury rating but that should only drive the salary down to a price that is worth the risk. The card we currently have isn't used much but this card would be used. Probably a 4 or 5 INJ
74
3%
50. 1996 Alex Rodriguez Seattle card! 358 batting led league 414 onBase 631 slugging, 1L Balance, SS-2e17
83
3%
 
Total votes : 2809

  • Author
  • Message
Offline

BC15NY

  • Posts: 457
  • Joined: Fri Sep 26, 2014 7:43 am

19.1 Voting is open!

PostSun Feb 03, 2019 8:00 am

Choose your top 15 cards. The top 25 overall will be sent to Strat on 2/18 (poll open for 2 weeks).

Thanks,
Bill
Offline

DanTheMan

  • Posts: 2
  • Joined: Mon Sep 11, 2017 8:52 pm

Re: 19.1 Voting is open!

PostThu Feb 14, 2019 6:21 pm

1981 Kirk Gibson .328, .369, slugging .479, OPS .848. Strike shortened season with 9 home runs in 290 at bats. 17 stolen bases. Gibby nearly led Detroit to the Division Title until beaten by a tough Milwaukee team on the last day.
Offline

BC15NY

  • Posts: 457
  • Joined: Fri Sep 26, 2014 7:43 am

Re: 19.1 Voting is closed!

PostThu Feb 14, 2019 9:55 pm

This thread is for 19.1 voting only.

Thanks,
Bill

Return to --- ATG Card Discussions

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest