Page 190 of 239

Re: 24 TKL Let's Play Two League Chat

PostPosted: Tue Aug 07, 2018 5:36 pm
by Ocello1126
jbenson27 wrote:
The Turtle wrote:Proposed rule change: Active rosters shall be increased to 28 (rather than 25) starting with the 2019 season.

It will take 16 "yes" votes for this to pass.

Yes - 5 (joker, coach, turtle,jbenson27, Ocello1126)

No - 1 (TVF)

Re: 24 TKL Let's Play Two League Chat

PostPosted: Tue Aug 07, 2018 7:45 pm
by calbatross
Proposed rule change: Active rosters shall be increased to 28 (rather than 25) starting with the 2019 season.

It will take 16 "yes" votes for this to pass.

Yes - 6 (joker, coach, turtle,jbenson27, Ocello1126, calbatross)

No - 1 (TVF)



For the sake of the enjoyment of the Strat game, to avoid the potential for petty disputes, and to make roster management easier for all, I vote Yes. Why would we want to put our commissioner in the unenviable position of having to penalize an owner for forgetting to send a guy to the minors after an injury? ;) -Cal

Re: 24 TKL Let's Play Two League Chat

PostPosted: Tue Aug 07, 2018 9:08 pm
by Apollo 21
I'm torn, so not posting a vote yet - just thoughts.

I think the 25-man roster is ideal, as it feels more realistic to me and I like the challenge of having to manage around roster constraints. However, I also agree that the current rule is somewhat unenforceable and requires a level of attentiveness that not everyone is always able to meet. So, again, I'm torn...

Re: 24 TKL Let's Play Two League Chat

PostPosted: Wed Aug 08, 2018 12:04 am
by kurtz2001
I vote yes.

Re: 24 TKL Let's Play Two League Chat

PostPosted: Wed Aug 08, 2018 7:25 am
by bobzilla23
I vote no.

Re: 24 TKL Let's Play Two League Chat

PostPosted: Wed Aug 08, 2018 7:43 am
by rvalente01
I vote no. it takes 10 seconds to add a player to your roster when someone is hurt . If a player in MLB is out for 3 days teams don't add a player they use another player on their active roster we get to add a player if we so choose and not drop the hurt player. If you cant take 10 seconds to add a player maybe you need find something else to do with your free time or don't draft players with more than a 1 injury rating. I've had 9 different players get hurt and lost 94 games due to injury I don't see it as an issue that I need a 28 man active roster for the full season.

Re: 24 TKL Let's Play Two League Chat

PostPosted: Wed Aug 08, 2018 9:56 am
by ed1447
Proposed rule change: Active rosters shall be increased to 28 (rather than 25) starting with the 2019 season.

It will take 16 "yes" votes for this to pass.

Yes - 7 (joker, coach, turtle,jbenson27, Ocello1126, calbatross, kurtz)

No - 3 (TVF, bobzilla, rvalente)

Re: 24 TKL Let's Play Two League Chat

PostPosted: Wed Aug 08, 2018 10:00 am
by ed1447
I am still pondering this issue too. I like the 25-man roster because it requires more thought than 28. But understand what others are saying too. As for enforcing 25-man roster, I rely on people to police themselves. Occasionally if I see a roster over the limit, I will send a reminder to drop a player (as has tvf33). But I am fully confident that no one is intentionally keeping a roster over 25 to gain an advantage.

Apollo 21 wrote:I'm torn, so not posting a vote yet - just thoughts.

I think the 25-man roster is ideal, as it feels more realistic to me and I like the challenge of having to manage around roster constraints. However, I also agree that the current rule is somewhat unenforceable and requires a level of attentiveness that not everyone is always able to meet. So, again, I'm torn...

Re: 24 TKL Let's Play Two League Chat

PostPosted: Wed Aug 08, 2018 10:14 am
by DLosier
I vote no.

Re: 24 TKL Let's Play Two League Chat

PostPosted: Wed Aug 08, 2018 10:34 am
by TVF33
Proposed rule change: Active rosters shall be increased to 28 (rather than 25) starting with the 2019 season.

It will take 16 "yes" votes for this to pass.

Yes - 7 (joker, coach, turtle,jbenson27, Ocello1126, calbatross, kurtz)

No - 4 (TVF, bobzilla, rvalente, DLosier)